Uber vs. DoorDash vs. Instacart: Which is the best gig app for You?

Home » Uber vs. DoorDash vs. Instacart: Which is the best gig app for You?
Young freelancer using a gig app on smartphone while working remotely in 2025.
The future of flexible work: Gig apps are transforming side hustles in 2025.

Gig apps now make it easier to find flexible work.

Whether you earn extra cash, a parent needs part -time hours, or a person is looking for full -time revenue with control over his plan, can help platforms like Uber, Dordash and Instacart. With the correct information you can choose the best gaming job yourself. The GIG economy is growing. It gives people the freedom to choose when and how much they work. It works well for both part -time and full -time workers.

Freelancers get more control over their time. But they may deal with income that changes week to week. Companies benefit from flexible workers, but may find it hard to keep them long-term. Artificial intelligence is changing how the gig economy works. It helps companies match workers with jobs faster. AI also automates tasks that used to be done by people, which saves time and lowers mistakes. Gig work can often be done from anywhere. Many workers like this. They can work from home or even while traveling.

However, in this detailed guide, we’ll discuss the pros and cons, earnings, flexibility, and overall experience of Uber, DoorDash, and Instacart to help you choose the right gig app.

What Is a Gig App?

 To begin with, before we dive into comparisons, let’s quickly understand what a gig app is.

A gig app connects independent workers (called gig workers) to customers who need services like rides, food delivery, or grocery shopping. Workers can pick when, where, and how often they work—no long-term contracts—just freedom and flexibility.

 

"Smiling Uber driver waiting for a ride request in Chicago, 2025"
An Uber driver in Chicago is ready to accept the next ride through the gig app.

Uber: Drive People Around

What is Uber?

Uber is a ride-hailing app where drivers use their own cars to give people rides. While Uber also has a food delivery service called Uber Eats, here focusing on the ride-share part. Uber is available in Chicago. It’s a good option for students or part-time workers because you can choose your own hours. It’s also a fast way to start earning without a long-term commitment. You can sign up and start driving with Uber anytime.

How It Works:

  • Sign up, pass a background check, and upload your documents.
  • Use your car to accept ride requests via the Uber Driver app.
  • Drive passengers to their destinations and get paid.

Pros of Uber:

  • Higher Earning Potential in Busy Cities: Surge pricing during rush hours or events can significantly increase earnings.
  • Instant Pay: Cash out daily with Uber’s Instant Pay feature.
  • Passive Income Options: If you rent out your vehicle or drive premium rides, you can earn more.
  • In-App Navigation: Uber’s app helps with directions and safety alerts.

Cons of Uber:

  • Higher Vehicle Requirements: Must have a relatively newer vehicle in good condition.
  • Wear and Tear on Vehicle: More driving = more maintenance costs.
  • Strict Ratings System: Riders rate drivers, and low ratings can lead to deactivation.

Best for:

  • People who love driving and don’t mind interacting with passengers.
  • Those with clean driving records and reliable cars.
  • City dwellers are looking for high-demand areas.

DoorDash: Deliver Food Fast

DoorDash delivering groceries in Chicago neighborhood, 2025, Best Gig App
A DoorDash driver drops off a fresh grocery order to a customer’s doorstep in Chicago what one of the Best Gig App

What is DoorDash?

On the other hand, DoorDash is a food delivery platform where Dashers pick up meals from local restaurants and deliver them to customers. DoorDash is a go-to platform for food delivery in Chicago. Operating in every major neighbourhood, it ensures wide coverage. Users can also enjoy weekly payouts, which is a big plus for gig workers. Top Delivery Apps for Side Hustlers.

How It Works:

Sign up, complete a background check, and receive a delivery bag. Become a DoorDash Dasher.

Pros of DoorDash:

  • Quick and Easy Start: You don’t need a fancy car—bikes and scooters work too in some cities.
  • Flexible Scheduling: You can dash anytime, anywhere.
  • Peak Pay Bonuses: Earn more during busy hours.
  • Lower Interaction: No passengers—just food hand-offs.

Cons of DoorDash:

  • Lower Pay in Slow Times: If demand drops, so do your earnings.
  • Restaurant Waits: Time spent waiting at restaurants can eat into profits.
  • Tip Dependency: Tips often make up a significant part of your income.

Best for:

  • Those who prefer solo work without driving passengers.
  • Students or part-timers looking for flexible earnings.

Instacart: Shop & Deliver Groceries

Instacart shopper delivering groceries in Chicago neighborhood, the Best Gig App in 2025
An Instacart shopper drops off a fresh grocery order to a customer’s doorstep in Chicago is the Best Gig App.

What is Instacart?

Likewise, Instacart offers another popular gig opportunity, but this one focuses on groceries. You’ll either just shop (in-store shopper) or shop and deliver (full-service shopper).

How It Works:

Accept batches (grocery orders) on the app.

Shop for the items, check out, and deliver them. Start earning with Instacart

Pros of Instacart:

  • Good Pay Per Batch: Especially for larger orders.
  • Fewer Deliveries Per Hour: One batch can take an hour, but it pays well.
  • Repeat Customers and Tips: Regular customers may tip more for good service.
  • Grocery Store Access: Some workers enjoy shopping and walking around.

Cons of Instacart:

  • Heavy Lifting: Carrying water bottles or bulk items can be physically demanding.
  • Time-Consuming Orders: Out-of-stock items or picky customers can slow you down.
  • Less Availability in Rural Areas: Less demand in non-urban zones.

Best for:

  • People who like grocery shopping and detail-oriented work.
  • Workers in suburban and urban areas.
  • Those who prefer less time on the road and more time in stores.

Now that we’ve explored the three platforms individually, let’s look at how they compare in terms of average earnings.

Moreover, App Average Hourly Pay* Bonuses Tip Potential Work Type
Uber: $18–$25 Surge Pricing Moderate Passenger rides
DoorDash: $15–$22 Peak Pay + Challenges High (most users tip) Food delivery
Instacart: $15–$20 Batch Incentives High Grocery delivery
*Note: Earnings vary based on location, time of day, and experience.

Flexibility & Scheduling

When it comes to work-life balance, all three apps offer excellent flexibility, but with slight differences.

Uber: Log in anytime, but rides may be unpredictable.

DoorDash: You can “Dash Now” or schedule ahead.

Instacart: Best orders often appear in the morning and early afternoon.

Ease of Getting Started

Uber: More requirements—license, registration, insurance, newer car.

DoorDash: Easiest—basic background check and delivery bag.

Instacart: Simple signup, but requires shopping and phone skills.

Safety & Support

Uber: In-app safety features like an emergency button and trip tracking.

DoorDash: Customer support is responsive; dashers can decline bad orders.

Instacart: In-app chat with customers helps resolve order issues.

Pro Tip: Always carry a phone charger and follow local safety guidelines!

Expenses to Keep in Mind to Choose the Best gig app

IRS Tax Tips for Gig Workers

However, it’s important to remember that all three gig apps come with expenses:

  • Gas & Car Maintenance
  • Vehicle Insurance
  • Phone Plan (with data)
  • Tax Withholding (you’re a 1099 contractor)

Still not sure? Here’s a quick breakdown to help you decide which gig app best fits your lifestyle.

Choose Uber if:

  • You have a newer car and enjoy driving people.
  • You live in a big city with high ride demand.
  • You’re looking for potentially higher pay during peak hours.

What about DoorDash if:

  • You prefer delivering food over people.
  • You want fast cash and quick trips.
  • You live in a city or town with lots of restaurants.

How amazing Instacart if:

  • You enjoy shopping and attention to detail.
  • You’re comfortable carrying groceries.
  • You want fewer deliveries with potentially higher batch pay.

Real-Life Experiences: What Gig Workers Say

Driving with Uber – Malik from Chicago

To give you a better picture, here are real-life experiences from current gig workers:
“I like talking to people, so this job suits me well. Friday and Saturday nights are gold mines. I once made $350 in 8 hours during a music festival!”

Takeaway: If you enjoy city nightlife and meeting people, Uber can be very rewarding, especially during events or holidays.

Dashing with DoorDash – Emily from Austin
“DoorDash gives me full control. I only work lunch and dinner rush. I average $22/hour because I know which restaurants are fast and which areas tip better.”

Takeaway: Knowing your local area and customer behavior can increase earnings.

Shopping with Instacart – Raj from Phoenix
“I like to stay indoors in the summer heat. Instacart let users buy grocery articles online and offer a delivery of a day. It is a partner with large grocery stores, making it a practical option for busy Chicago residents. The key is tackled and avoiding orders with many water cases!”

Takeaway: Physical demands exist, but strategic order selection can help you avoid burnout.

Pro Tips to Maximize Earnings on Each App

No matter which platform you choose, these expert tips can help you maximize your earnings:

Uber:

  • Track Your Expenses: Use apps like Grid wise or Ever lance to track mileage and expenses for tax deductions.
  • Work During Surge Hours: Mornings (7–9 am), evenings (5–8 pm), and weekends = $$$.
  • Drive Premium: If eligible, Uber XL or Comfort trips pay more.

DoorDash:

  • Decline Low-Pay Orders: Use the “decline” button for low-paying deliveries—your acceptance rate doesn’t impact access.
  • Use Hotspots Wisely: Stay near clusters of high-demand restaurants.
  • Stack Orders: When possible, accept stacked deliveries for higher earnings per trip.

Instacart:

  • Check Item Count & Distance: A $30 batch with 10 items and 3 miles is better than a $40 batch with 50 items and 15 miles.
  • Shop Smart: Know your local stores well—it speeds up shopping time.
  • Batch Early: Log in early in the day to grab high-paying orders before others.

The Power of Multi-Apping

To boost income even further, many gig workers use multiple apps to maximize their time and profits. Here’s how:

What is Multi-Apping?
Multi-apping means working for more than one platform at once. For example:

In addition, accept a DoorDash order during a slow Uber shift.

Decline low-paying batches on Instacart while checking for surges on Uber.

Tips for Safe and Smart Multi-Apping:
Don’t Overcommit: Only accept one order at a time unless they’re in the same direction.

Use One Phone with Split Screen (or Two Phones): Keep both apps open and monitor both dashboards.

Know Peak Times: Schedule Uber for morning rush, DoorDash for lunch/dinner, and Instacart for mornings.

Example Schedule:

  • Time App Used Why
  • 7–10 am Uber Morning commute surge
  • 10–2 pm Instacart Grocery demand peaks
  • 5–9 pm DoorDash Dinner rush high tips
  • Advanced Metrics to Track

Moreover, successful gig workers don’t just “wing it.” They analyse key performance stats:

Metric What It Means

  • Earnings Per Hour: Total earnings ÷ total hours worked
  • Mileage Efficiency Earnings per mile driven
  • Tip Rate: How much of your income comes from tips
  • Acceptance/Completion: How many orders do you accept/complete
  • Customer Ratings Keep above the minimum to avoid deactivation

Use free tools like:

  • Gridwise
  • Stride
  • Hurdlr

Para (for multi-app support)

Frequently Asked Questions about Best gig app (FAQ)

Still have questions? Here are some frequently asked questions:

1. Can I do this full-time?
Yes, many people do gig work full-time. You’ll need to budget carefully and maintain your vehicle.

2. What if I have an older car?
DoorDash and Instacart are more lenient than Uber. You may not qualify for Uber if your vehicle is too old or doesn’t meet local standards.

3. Do I need to talk to people?

  • Uber: Yes, you interact with passengers.
  • DoorDash: Minimal contact, usually just food hand-offs.
  • Instacart: You may need to message customers about out-of-stock items.

4. What about safety?
All apps have safety features like GPS tracking and emergency buttons. Always trust your instincts and avoid unsafe situations or neighbourhoods, especially at night.

5. Do I get benefits?
“Independent contractors working under a 1099 status usually miss out on traditional employee perks such as health insurance or vacation pay, but they can lower their taxable income by deducting business-related costs. Under the future predictions or technology section.”

“While 1099 contractors don’t have access to benefits like employer-sponsored health plans or paid leave, they do have the advantage of claiming tax deductions for expenses tied to their work.”

How Location Affects Your Earnings Using the Best Gig App in 2025

Additionally, your earnings depend heavily on where you live. Here’s a general guide for the Best gig app:

  • Area Type Best App(s) Why
  • Large Cities: Uber, DoorDash. High population = high demand
  • Suburbs Instacart, DoorDash Families = grocery delivery
  • Rural Areas Instacart (limited) might need to travel farther
  • Some areas offer “Zone Bonuses” or guaranteed earnings, especially when new drivers are needed.

Should You Try All Three First?

Finally, should you try all three platforms first? Absolutely! Each platform has its pros and cons, and your experience may differ from someone else’s. Here’s how to test all three:

  • Sign up for all apps and work each one for 1 week.
  • Track your hours, earnings, and effort.
  • Most people settle on 2 apps they rotate between for flexibility and fallback options.

Your Path to Flexible Income with the Best Gig Apps in today’s faster-growing economy.

As a result, choosing between Uber, DoorDash, and Instacart is about more than just pay. It’s about your lifestyle, preferences, and comfort.

  • If you’re a confident driver who doesn’t mind small talk, Uber is for you.
  • DoorDash is ideal if you want quick trips, high tips, and low interaction.
  • Instacart fits well if you love shopping, organisation, and solo work.

The best part? You can start today. These platforms are designed to get you earning within days.

  • No resumes.
  • No suits.

Just hustle and a smart strategy.

Whether you want part-time cash or full-time flexibility, there’s a gig app that can fit into your life.

Can You Use Multiple Best gig Apps?
For example, Many gig workers use multiple apps to maximise their earnings. You can drive for Uber in the morning, Dash during lunch, and deliver groceries in the afternoon. Just make sure to manage your time wisely and avoid overlapping schedules.

Final Verdict: Best Gig App in 2025?
Ultimately, all three platforms offer unique opportunities. The “best” gig app isn’t universal—it’s personal.

  • For social drivers, Uber wins.
  • For fast-paced delivery, DoorDash delivers.
  • For organised shoppers: Instacart shines.

Finally, should you try all three platforms first?  Try each platform for a week or two and track your earnings, hours, and experience. Then decide which one fits your lifestyle best.

Top Gigs
DoorDash

Deliver food on your schedule and earn fast with DoorDash — flexible, fast, and easy to start.

Lyft

Drive with Lyft and earn on your own terms with flexible hours and fast payouts.

Uber

Earn on your own schedule by driving with Uber — flexible, fast, and available in most cities.

Fiverr

Sell your skills online with Fiverr — create gigs, set your price, and work from anywhere.

BestGigJobs.com is compensated by companies listed on this site. This compensation may influence how and where offers appear (including their order). We may earn commissions from qualifying activities. BestGigJobs.com is not responsible for any damages or losses you may experience. © 2025 BestGigJobs.com, a SupplyUSA LLC website. All Rights Reserved.